Subscribe
0%
Illustration for: Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook's default-on Android gallery access: what the ruling requires

Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook's default-on Android gallery access: what the ruling requires

Italy's privacy regulator says Facebook's "suggestions from gallery" feature read Android users' photos and videos without specific consent, and gave Meta 60 days to make it opt-in. The case sidesteps Ireland's lead role in policing Meta, a route other EU regulators could also take.

Listen to this article0:00 / 4:32

Italy's data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, fined Meta €805 million (about $887 million) on Saturday, November 14, for letting the Facebook app on Android read users' photo and video galleries without specific consent. The regulator puts the fine at about 0.47% of Meta's global turnover, according to AP and Italian outlet Open.

Why it matters: the fine is large, and it comes from Rome rather than Dublin. The Garante used the EU's ePrivacy rules, which have no "one-stop-shop" sending cases to Meta's lead regulator in Ireland. If that reasoning holds up, other national regulators could take the same route for any app that reads data on a user's phone.

What the Garante found

The case centres on a Facebook feature the company calls "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook." It launched in 2023 and suggests photos and videos from the phone's camera roll for users to post, according to Open and Il Fatto Quotidiano. The regulator's findings, as reported by Open, AP and Il Fatto Quotidiano:

  • One permission, many purposes. Facebook asked for gallery access through a single permission covering the whole app and several unrelated functions.
  • Vague prompt. The permission request used a generic "enable other features" notice that didn't mention gallery suggestions.
  • On by default. The feature was switched on unless users turned it off.
  • Full archive access. Once granted, the app could read the whole photo archive, usually permanently, with no way for users or the regulator to check what was actually used.

The Garante relied on Article 122 of Italy's privacy code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive. It says any access to information stored on a smartphone needs free and informed consent, whether or not data leaves the device or harm results. Meta Platforms Ireland argued the case belonged to the Irish regulator. The Garante rejected that argument.

How it got here and why the fine is so large

The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano consumer group Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, followed by a technical analysis by Garante staff, per Open.

The regulator cited these factors in setting the amount, per Open and Il Fatto Quotidiano:

Factor What the Garante said
Scale Roughly 20 million Android users in Italy affected
Duration Still ongoing for users who haven't updated the app or had already enabled the feature
History A previous 2019 decision against Meta
Cooperation Limited cooperation during the probe
Mitigation Changes Meta made after the complaint counted, but were judged late and apply only to users who update

What Meta has to do

Within 60 days, Meta must show a separate, specific consent request for the feature that explains what it does, that it reads the camera roll, and how to turn it off. The feature has to stay off by default, including for users who previously agreed. Meta must tell the Garante what it plans within 30 days and what it has done within 90 days, Open reports. After the deadline, the feature can't run for anyone who hasn't given valid consent.

What the ruling doesn't cover

The investigation did not examine whether gallery content was used to train AI models; Meta denies doing so, according to Investing.com and Il Fatto Quotidiano. The Garante says it may separately investigate a 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud, per Bloomberg via The Spokesman-Review.

Meta did not immediately comment, AP and Bloomberg reported. Open's headline says the company has announced an appeal, but the article text we could read didn't include a Meta statement, so treat that as unconfirmed.

What to do if you use Facebook on Android

You don't have to wait for Meta's 60-day deadline:

  1. In the Facebook app, open the menu, then Settings and Privacy → Settings → Camera roll sharing suggestions, and switch off both toggles. That's the path Tom's Guide documented when Meta's camera-roll processing first drew attention in 2025; menus can move between app versions.
  2. In Android's own settings, find Facebook under Apps → Permissions and limit photo and video access to selected items or don't allow. The "selected items" option exists on recent Android versions; either way, the system permission limits what the app can read regardless of Facebook's in-app settings.

What to watch: whether Meta appeals, whether the Garante opens the cloud-processing case, and whether other EU privacy regulators start using ePrivacy to bring device-access cases against big platforms without going through Ireland.

Sources

  1. Open — Meta, maxi multa da 805 milioni dal Garante Privacy: le foto Android usate senza consenso open.online
  2. ABC News (AP) — Meta fined $887M in Italy over Android gallery photos, videos on Facebook abcnews.com
  3. Investing.com — Italy fines Meta €805 million over access to Android users' photos investing.com
  4. Il Fatto Quotidiano — Multa Meta 805 milioni: Garante Privacy sanziona Facebook per accesso foto ilfattoquotidiano.it
  5. The Spokesman-Review (Bloomberg) — Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Access to Users' Photos spokesman.com
  6. Tom's Guide — Meta might be accessing your camera roll without permission: here's the fix tomsguide.com

#Meta#Facebook#Garante#Italy#privacy#ePrivacy#Android#regulation