Subscribe
0%
Illustration for: Apple TV 4K (4th gen) review roundup: A19 and hands-free Siri make it the best streamer, but $299 is a hard sell

Apple TV 4K (4th gen) review roundup: A19 and hands-free Siri make it the best streamer, but $299 is a hard sell

Apple's new Apple TV 4K reached stores on November 13 after the first hands-on reviews landed. Engadget, 9to5Mac and MacRumors agree it is the best streaming box you can buy, and that owners of the 2021 or 2022 model should mostly keep what they have, since Siri AI is coming to those too.

Listen to this article0:00 / 4:07
8.0/10

Recommended

The measured verdict

Reviewers call it the best streaming box available, with a faster A19, hands-free Siri and HomePod surround sound. But one $299 configuration is double the old entry price, and Siri AI is also coming to the 2021 and 2022 models, so most current owners can skip it.

Price: $299

What we like

  • Hands-free Siri via three far-field microphones
  • A19 chip and a new AV1 decoder
  • Precision Finding and a locate sound for the new Siri Remote
  • Four-HomePod surround support
  • Wi-Fi 7, Ethernet and Thread smart home hub in every unit, per 9to5Mac

What we don't

  • $299 single 128GB configuration; the cheaper Wi-Fi-only model is gone
  • Siri AI is a beta and stumbles on follow-ups and on-screen context
  • Siri AI is English-only in eight countries at launch and needs an Apple Intelligence iPhone or iPad
  • Speed gains are hard to notice in everyday streaming
  • Precision Finding needs a recent iPhone

Synthesized from named hands-on reviews by Engadget (Billy Steele), 9to5Mac (Chance Miller) and MacRumors, plus Apple's specifications. TechMeasured did not test this unit; the rating is our editorial summary of those reviews.

Apple's fourth-generation Apple TV 4K went on sale in stores on Friday, November 13, a month after Apple announced it. The first hands-on reviews published on November 12 agree on two things: it is still the best streaming box you can buy, and its $299 price makes it much harder to recommend than before.

That matters because the headline feature this time is AI, not picture quality. Reviewers found that the hands-free Siri AI is convenient but still a beta. It is also coming to the two previous models, which takes away much of the reason for current owners to upgrade.

What's new, according to Apple

Apple TV 4K (4th gen)
Price $299 (US), one configuration
Storage 128GB (per Engadget and 9to5Mac)
Chip A19; Apple claims up to 50% faster CPU and up to 2x faster GPU than the previous model
Video New dedicated AV1 decoder
Voice Three far-field microphones for "Siri" / "Hey Siri" without the remote
Networking Wi-Fi 7 and Ethernet (per 9to5Mac); Thread for smart home
Audio Up to four HomePod (2nd gen) or HomePod mini 2 speakers as surround, in matched front and rear pairs
On sale Pre-orders from October 13; in stores November 13

Apple says microphone audio is processed in a Secure Exclave that tvOS, apps and Apple cannot access, and that Siri requests run on-device or in its Private Cloud Compute. The new Siri Remote supports Precision Finding in Find My, but only with an iPhone 17 or later (not the 17e), iPhone Air or iPhone Duo. 9to5Mac says the remote is also sold on its own for $59 and works with older Apple TV 4K models.

What the reviewers found

Engadget (Billy Steele, 8.5/10) calls it the best streaming box available. He highlights the speed of the A19, the remote finder, the smart home hub features and HomePod surround sound. His complaints are the price, which he says is $150 more than the equivalent previous model cost at launch, and the end of the cheaper Wi-Fi-only version. He also notes that the four-HomePod setup requires all four speakers in one room, and that tvOS still has no dedicated Home app.

9to5Mac (Chance Miller, 10 days of testing) found hands-free Siri worked relatively well. Recommendation queries return a full-screen view with poster art and cast information. Questions about what was playing were less reliable, because Siri sometimes identified the wrong title. He says the speed gains are hard to notice day to day. He would only reluctantly pay $299, noting that earlier models launched at $179 and the 2022 model at $129.

MacRumors says Siri AI is better than the old Siri but answered follow-up questions only some of the time. The box can recognize up to six people for personalized recommendations. MacRumors' advice is that owners of the 2nd- or 3rd-generation models probably shouldn't upgrade.

Siri AI fine print

  • Apple labels Siri AI a beta. At launch it is English-only in the US, UK, Canada, Australia, India, New Zealand, Singapore and South Africa.
  • It requires the home's owner to have an Apple Intelligence-capable iPhone or iPad. Apple says it isn't initially available in the EU on iOS or iPadOS.
  • Apple says some server-side features have daily limits, and expanded access will cost money in the future.
  • Apple says Apple TV 4K (2nd generation) and later will also get Siri AI. MacRumors says this will come in tvOS 27.2.1. Only the far-field microphones are exclusive to the new model.

Should you buy it?

  • You own a 2021 or 2022 Apple TV 4K: Keep it. Siri AI is coming to your box, and Engadget and MacRumors both advise against upgrading. If you mainly want the remote finder, the new $59 Siri Remote works with older models (Precision Finding needs a recent iPhone).
  • You have an Apple TV HD or older: MacRumors says owners of older models may find the new features worth the price, especially if you want hands-free Siri or plan to use HomePods as surround speakers.
  • First-time buyer on a budget: Engadget suggests waiting for a sale or buying a refurbished or used third-generation model.

Sources

  1. Apple Newsroom — Apple unveils the new Apple TV 4K apple.com
  2. Engadget — Apple TV 4K (4th gen) review: Still great, but drastically more expensive engadget.com
  3. 9to5Mac — Apple TV 4K review: The best streamer comes at a cost 9to5mac.com
  4. MacRumors — Hands-On With the New Apple TV 4K and Siri AI macrumors.com

#Apple#Apple TV 4K#A19#Siri AI#tvOS#HomePod#streaming#review roundup