Subscribe
0%
Illustration for: Harvard: the 403 largest US data centers used about 82 TWh in a year and emitted more CO2 than Denmark. What the numbers show

Harvard: the 403 largest US data centers used about 82 TWh in a year and emitted more CO2 than Denmark. What the numbers show

A Harvard-led study in Nature Sustainability estimates that the biggest US data centers used about 1.8% of the country's electricity between May 2024 and April 2025, more than half of it from fossil fuels. Operators don't publish per-site figures, so the result is a modelled estimate, and the emissions number is far lower than the one in the team's June preprint.

Listen to this article0:00 / 4:08

A Harvard-led team estimates that the 403 largest data centers in the US used about 82 terawatt-hours of electricity between May 2024 and April 2025. That is roughly 1.8% of all US electricity use. By the team's estimate, their carbon dioxide emissions exceeded Denmark's entire national output. The study was published on November 16 in Nature Sustainability, according to Spectrum News 1 and Hardware Busters. Gianluca Guidi, a postdoctoral fellow, led the work, and biostatistics professor Francesca Dominici was senior author.

Why it matters: data-center operators don't disclose power use or emissions site by site. That makes outside estimates like this one some of the few public numbers in the fight over who pays for AI's electricity. The study came out the same day Turkey and the ITU launched a voluntary clean-AI pledge at COP31.

The headline numbers

Measure Published study, as reported Source
Sites 403 hyperscale data centers Spectrum News 1, The Hill
Period May 2024 – April 2025 all
Electricity ~82 TWh (range 68–99 TWh) Hardware Busters, The Hill
Share of US use ~1.8% The Hill
Homes equivalent ~7 million homes for a year Spectrum News 1
CO2 25.7 million metric tonnes (28.3 million US short tons) The Hill, Hardware Busters
Fossil share ~54%: 30% natural gas, 15% coal The Hill
Top states Virginia, Ohio, Oregon, Iowa: more than half the electricity The Hill
Versus earlier work 2–3x higher than a 2018-based estimate The Hill, Spectrum News 1

Dominici compared the total to the emissions of a state like Michigan or a small European country, Hardware Busters reports.

How the estimate was made, and why the number moved

We couldn't read the published paper. The team's June preprint on arXiv explains the method. The team took each facility's electrical capacity from the Baxtel data-center database and checked it against OpenStreetMap footprints and satellite imagery. It multiplied that capacity by the hours in a year and by an assumed utilisation rate. It then assigned the resulting demand to power plants in the local grid balancing area, using EPA eGRID 2023 data. The authors describe the totals as "bounded scenario-based estimates," not measurements.

The electricity estimate matches what was published: about 82 TWh in the central scenario, within a 68–99 TWh range. The emissions estimate doesn't. The preprint put CO2 at roughly 37–54 million tonnes, with about 45 Mt in the central case. That reflects an average grid intensity of about 545 g CO2/kWh for these sites, about 48% above the 2023 US average, according to the preprint. The published figure of 25.7 Mt is roughly 40% lower than that central case. None of the coverage we read explains the change. The fuel mix also differs: the preprint gives 38% natural gas, while The Hill reports 30% for the published version. Treat the published figure as the authoritative one, and expect the method behind it to have changed after peer review.

The preprint's other findings may also have shifted in the final version. Virginia ranked first by emissions, and about 90% of demand sat in grid regions dirtier than the national average.

Limits worth knowing

  • Modelled, not metered. Utilisation is an assumption. The authors say the study doesn't observe which sites run AI workloads and which run general-purpose ones.
  • It's a snapshot. The window ends in April 2025. Guidi told The Hill the boom "hasn't slowed down" since then. Dominici pointed to about 2,000 more data centers in planning, Hardware Busters reports.
  • Annual averages. The preprint uses yearly grid averages, not hourly or marginal emissions. Hourly or marginal figures could push the result in either direction, and so could on-site generation.

What to watch

The Hill reports that Sen. Josh Hawley called on November 11 for a moratorium on data-center construction. A bipartisan group of senators wants to speed up the buildout while making developers pay more for their power. Malaysia is already moving to force power disclosure from operators. As Cornell's Fengqi You told reporters, reliable measurement depends on that kind of disclosure. Until operators publish metered, site-level data, estimates like this one, and their revisions, are the best available numbers.

Sources

  1. arXiv — Guidi, Dominici et al., Assessing the Carbon Emissions and Energy Consumption of U.S. Hyperscale Data Centers (preprint) arxiv.org
  2. The Hill via Yahoo News — US data centers emit more greenhouse gases than Denmark, Harvard study finds yahoo.com
  3. Hardware Busters — Harvard puts data center emissions from the 400 largest US sites above all of Denmark hwbusters.com
  4. Spectrum News 1 — Harvard study: largest U.S. data centers emit more carbon than all of Denmark spectrumnews1.com

#data centers#Harvard#carbon emissions#electricity#AI infrastructure#COP31#energy